Bennie Railplane (1930)
Overhead Streamlined Trains
Inventors have turned their attention to new systems of railway transport giving high speeds to compete with motor-car and air transport and to retain the safety of railway travel. On ordinary railways it is not the building of steam, electric, or Diesel locomotives to travel at high speeds which presents the chief difficulty, but the problem of keeping them stable on the tracks on which they run.
In 1930 a German, Herr Paul Kruckenburg, fitted an air screw propeller to a passenger coach weighing twenty-eight tons. The air screw was driven by a 600 h.p. oil engine and hauled the coach along a specially prepared length of track in German at a speed at over 140 miles an hour. Herr Kruckenburg did not take chances; his trial track had all movable points removed and there were no curves. His line was dead straight; had he run on to a curve at that speed his coach would have been flung off the rails like a stone from a string. The results of Herr Kruckenburg's experiments have given encouragement to inventors who are studying this problem of high speed, and they have also demonstrated that the limit of speed on railway tracks is confined to the tracks and not to the locomotives. [The correct name is Franz Kruckenberg.]
Realisation of these limitations has led inventors to develop their ideas of high-speed railways on lines different from those of conventional railways. One of the most interesting of these inventions is the railplane system of transport. This is a monorail system, the cars being hung from an overhead rail. When this system was introduced the idea seemed to be somewhat bizarre but there were those who saw possibilities in the system, and the railplane has been developed. It is claimed to be one of the fastest, safest and cheapest means of land transport. A length of track has been erected over a section of the L.N.E.R. near Glasgow. The track is complete with equipment and a railplane car has been installed, It is known as the Railplane Test Line, and many interesting tests and experiments have been made.
The system consists of streamlined cars which are suspended from bogies running on a single overhead rail, and propelled by air screw propellers. The propellers are driven either by Diesel engines or by electric motors.
The track is of lattice box girder construction, supported at the desired height above the ground on steel trestles. These trestles are spaced about eighty feet apart along the track, and an advantage of the system is that very little ground is occupied. The only land required, apart from stations and depot sites, is that needed for the comparatively small concrete pads at the feet of the trestles.
Along the bottom of the lattice box girder, the main rail, on which the bogies run, is fixed. The illustrations show a double-track system, and there is a rail-bar fixed at either side of the bottom of the girder. The main rail is bolted to the top flange of this beam. A similar rail is bolted to the bottom flange, the use of which is explained later. There is ample room within the lattice girder for a patrol-way.
The system is a departure from the principles governing ordinary railway traction. Being a monorail, but with the cars slung from an overhead rail, the stability of the car at all speeds is automatic. With ordinary railways provision has to be made to counteract the centrifugal forces acting on the vehicles when travelling on curves, and this is done by raising the outer rail to tilt the vehicle towards the inside of the curve. This banking of track is known as super-elevation.
Safety on Curves
When railplane cars run on to a curve they tend to swing out and take up their natural amount of banking or super-elevation and, as the centre of gravity of each vehicle is always below its point of suspension on the track, it is stable in all conditions. The construction of the bogie carriages makes it impossible for the vehicles to he derailed. The bogie wheels have double flanges and the flanges are of such a depth as to be greater than the clearance between the bogie and the underside of the girder carrying the rail. Anything that made the car jump at all could raise it only by the amount of this clearance, as the flanges of the wheels would still be covering the sides of the main rail.
Railplane ears are streamlined, and thus they are able to overcome what will probably remain an insoluble problem in streamline vehicles running along the ground. The under-part of a land carriage can never be effectively streamlined and must always constitute a drag on the vehicle.
Each car is driven by air screws, one fore and one aft. Railplane cars can be run either singly or in trains of cars. When the cars are made up into trains, they will be coupled together, but each will be driven by its own propellers. The driver will be in the front cab of the first car, as in an ordinary electric train, and he will control the propellers throughout the train. The problem of making up railplane cars into trains has been solved be a coupling device which, while retaining perfect flexibility, revolves with the propeller shafts.
When Diesel engines are used the problems of driving the propellers are comparatively straight forward, but when electric motors are intended the conditions are different.
With an internal combustion engine, which develops, say, 100 horse power when the shaft is turning at the full speed, say, 1,000 revolutions per minute, the conditions are definite, and a propeller can be designed to take full advantage of those conditions. But if electric motors are to be used to drive propellers, a new field of development is opened up An electric motor which develops 100 horse power when the shalt is running at full speed - 1,000 revolutions per minute - may be designed to give double this power at a higher speed for fairly long periods.
There are various means of effecting this increase in the power of an electric motor, and the increase is given without any loss of efficiency. But the problem of designing a propeller to work efficiently when driven by an electric motor of 100 horse power at 1,000 revolutions per minute, and also to work efficiently when the power of the motor is increased by 100 per cent at a higher speed, called for an entirely new line of investigation.
The Propeller Thrust
The railplane engineer most consider the efficiency of his machine at every speed, from the moment he starts up to his top speed, which can be as high as over 200 miles per hour. The problems of the design of propellers to meet all the conditions of railplane operation have been solved, and British propeller makers can turn out propellers to fulfil these conditions. The solution of the difficulties brought to light the potential advantages of the railplane cars.
The railplane is not limited in the same way as railway locomotives and electric trains in accelerating from the "start" and retarding to "stop." The railways are obliged to rely on the weight of the vehicle to give the necessary grip on the rails.
With the railplane the power is expended in rotating a propeller in air. The propeller acts on the air, setting it in motion, and the reaction from the air supplies the "propeller thrust." In the railplane the "propeller thrust" is the "tractive effort." The "propeller thrust" depends upon the design of the propeller, and the character of the thrust is varied according to the type used. Thus the propeller may be designed to give extremely rapid or extremely slow acceleration.
Between these two extremes there is a range of railplane car performance to suit any set of service conditions. The same car can be used for short suburban trips and for long non-stop runs. There is no limit to the rate of acceleration on a railplane car beyond the comfort of the crew and passengers. It is merely a question of changing the propellers. The car performs all its tasks with the same degree of efficiency.
On roads and railways the retardation, or slowing down of a vehicle, is accomplished by various methods of braking the wheels. On the railplane mention has been made of a rail bolted on the underside of the rail beam. When the brakes are applied they do not grip the wheels of the railplane bogie. The brakes act by one brake shoe gripping the top rail and a second brake shoe gripping the bottom rail. There are two separate brakes on each bogie carriage. One is manually operated by the driver, and the other is controlled by the signalling system. Powerful springs control the amount of "grip" of the brake shoes on the rails, and by this method of braking the retardation can be adjusted to suit the service conditions. The retardation can, for instance, be set to be equal to that obtained with maximum braking on a London omnibus. This is about four times greater than the retardation allowed in railway practice.
Since the railplane does not have to depend upon the adhesion between the wheels and the rails to transmit the driving forces, it follows that the weight of the car can he cut down to a minimum. Modification and refinement of design have so far developed that the passenger car, for instance, will not haul very much more weight per passenger than an Imperial Airways liner. In one of the illustrations a light lattice girder is shown just beneath the car. This is the guide rail, and does not bear any of the weight of the car, its object is to prevent side swing.
Since it is necessary to reduce the weight of the car as much as possible, it is also necessary to reduce the effect of side winds and of the oscillations which would he set up when running on or off curves at high speeds. To this end horizontal wheels are fitted to engage on either side of the sway rail. The wheels are rubber-tyred and are controlled by springs to prevent bumping.
Signalling safeguards are more complete on this overhead system than is general on the standard railways, and the railplane can be started as well as stopped by the signals without any action on the driver’s part.
One of the brakes on each bogie carriage is interlocked by relays with the signals. The usual red, green, and yellow signals along the track are reproduced before the driver on a board in his cabin.
When the track is clear a green light glows on the signal panel before the driver. If he should run on a section which is not quite clear, the green light changes to yellow (caution). If the danger does not clear and the driver does not take precaution, the yellow light changes to red (danger) and the brakes are automatically applied, bringing the car to a standstill.
On an ordinary electric train the operation of bringing it to a standstill stops all the machinery, and, to restart, the controls must be again operated. On the railplane the brakes may bring the car to a standstill, but the motors and propellers need not stop. The propellers merely churn the air, and as soon as the line clears, the red light in the cab is replaced by the green light, the brakes are released and the thrust of the propeller starts the car going.
During ordinary service working the driver would make use of the propellers in reverse as an aid to braking. Railplane propellers of the fixed blade type have been designed to work efficiently in reverse. This is another indication of the problems solved by the railplane engineers.
There is very little noise from the railplane propellers, except at the start. They are designed to operate at 800 revolutions per minute, and they are nine feet in diameter. In these conditions the effective tips of the blades are travelling at less than the speed of sound, and the effect is comparative quiet. The inside of a railplane car will be quieter than the inside of a luxury train. There is little or no air disturbance. With the car travelling at full speed there would be a back draught of five miles per hour.
On a monorail such as that described the track resistance is reduced to a very small item. The test car at Glasgow weights seven and a half tons, and yet a man could easily walk along and push it with one hand, as the total track resistance is only forty-eight pounds.
The railplane can run up a gradient as steep as 1 in 27,. and thus the system would not require heavy and expensive earthworks and structures common to the ordinary railways. Bridges, tunnels, cuttings, and embankments would be eliminated, but at the same time the cost of erecting the continuous railplane track at well above ground level must not be overlooked.
The railplane is one of the most interesting proposals yet made for travelling at very high speed on a fixed rail cheaply and safely. The high rate of acceleration attained by railplanes should make them a factor in solving many operating problems, including those of rush-hour traffic. It has been estimated that a suburban railplane track, equipped with cars of the type illustrated, would carry over 12,000 passengers in either direction at an average of fifty miles miles an hour, including steps.
This article was taken from "Railway Wonders of the World" (1935).
The Bennie Railplane was a form of rail transport invented by George Bennie (1891–1957), which moved along an overhead rail by way of propellers. Bennie, born at Auldhouse, near Glasgow, Scotland began work on the development of his railplane in 1921. In 1929-1930 he built a prototype on a trial stretch of track over a 130-yard (119-metre) line at Milngavie, off the Glasgow and Milngavie Junction Railway, with one railplane car to demonstrate the system to potential clients. The car ran along an overhead monorail, stabilised by guide rails below. It moved by propellers powered by on-board motors.
It was intended to run above conventional railways, separating faster passenger traffic from slower freight traffic. Bennie believed his railplane cars had the capability of travelling up to 120 mph (193 km/h) and would offer a "fast passenger and mails and perishable goods service". Slow and heavy goods freight and local passenger services would continue on the traditional rail service below. Each car could carry a maximum of 48 people, although the prototype had seating for fewer.
In spite of interest from around the world, however, Bennie could not obtain the financial backing he required to develop his revolutionary transport system. The proposed line from Edinburgh to Glasgow was not built, nor was the one between Southport and Blackpool. By 1937, Bennie was bankrupt. He had financed most of the work himself. The prototype railplane lay rusting in a field at Milngavie until it was sold for scrap in 1956. Bennie died the following year. The original shed where the carriage was built in Main Street, Milngavie is now occupied by a timber merchant, and has a blue commemorative plaque on the outside wall.
Source: Wikipedia (2018)